I'll close this topic as resolved, and will describe my solution in case anybody gets the same issue, however, I have no idea of WHAT could have caused it.
It was an index.html file that was left in my root folder of my site and thats the page that was loading before anything else as my homepage. the plugin doesnt seem to create that file anymore for me, and for some reason, even after a full unninstall, the file was still left behind. So the solution was just to delete that file.